Kratky method research
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
| Main researcher | Bernard A. Kratky, horticulturist[8] |
|---|---|
| Institution | University of Hawaii College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resources (CTAHR)[8] |
| Trial sites | Hilo, Volcano and Mealani, Hawaii; State College, Pennsylvania[3][6][8] |
| Crops studied | Lettuce, watercress, cucumbers, tomatoes[1][6] |
| Main outlets | HortScience, HortTechnology, Acta Horticulturae, National Agricultural Plastics Congress, CTAHR bulletins |
| Award | American Society for Plasticulture Best Paper Award, 2008[7] |
Kratky method research is the published record of trials on passive, non-circulating hydroponics, in which a crop grows on a single fill of nutrient solution under a cover while a moist air space forms above the falling solution.[1] Most of it was carried out by Dr. Bernard A. Kratky and his colleagues at the University of Hawaii's College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resources, from tomato observations published in 1988 to a watercress bulletin in 2015.[6] Researchers elsewhere have also used the method as a low-cost test system for lettuce nutrition, growing media and urban food production.[9][10]
This section collects that record. The story of how the method developed is told in the history of the Kratky method; how each design is built is covered under Kratky system designs.
Research pages
| Page | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Publications on the Kratky method | Every patent, paper and bulletin Kratky's work cites on the method, with links where they are online |
| Three non-circulating lettuce methods (2009) | Kratky's 2009 Acta Horticulturae paper describing the bottle, covered tank and float-support designs |
| Kratky method water use and nutrient use | Liters of water per kilogram of crop, where the water goes, nitrogen use and salt build-up |
| Mosquito control research in Kratky tanks | Three University of Hawaii studies of Bti, methoprene and Pyronyl in lettuce tanks |
| Rain shelters in Kratky's research | The plastic-roofed structures Kratky tanks stand in: designs, cooling and yields |
| Kratky research notes | Short summaries of single studies, each with its methods, results and caveats |
| Kratky method studies by other researchers | Trials by other researchers since 2013, from Brazil to Uganda |
Main findings
Across Kratky's papers, the same results recur:
- One fill is enough for short crops. An entire crop can be grown with only an initial application of water and nutrients, and no electricity or pumps.[1]
- The air space matters. When the cover floated on the solution and no air space formed, lettuce yields fell by up to 23 percent compared with a cover held by the tank frame.[2]
- Water use is low. Lettuce used 11 to 14 liters of water per kilogram in Hawaii and 18 to 32 liters per kilogram in a warmer, windier Pennsylvania tunnel.[3] Details are on Kratky method water use.
- Nutrients are used efficiently. The Pennsylvania lettuce used 3.3 g of nitrogen per kilogram of lettuce, and topping off the leftover solution worked for at least three crops in a row.[3]
- pH rarely needs adjusting. In the Hawaii trials, crops were usually completed without altering pH when commercial hydroponic fertilizer and good water were used.[2]
- Water quality limits the method. Salts concentrate as the solution is used: water starting at 0.5 mS may reach 2.0 mS when a quarter of the solution remains, which can cause tipburn.[2]
Research by crop
| Crop | Systems tested | Reported result |
|---|---|---|
| Lettuce | Capillary tube, bottle, covered tank, float-support | Growers typically aim for 150 to 250 g heads, ready about 5 weeks after transplanting[2] |
| Watercress | Suspended net-pot tank and floating cover | Net pots direct-seeded with 10 to 20 seeds, or planted with seedlings 1 to 3 weeks old[6] |
| Cucumber | 100 to 130 L trash container | Over 7 kg per 120 L container in cool weather; half of that is a normal expectation[1] |
| Tomato | 757 L fill-once tank; maintained-level containers | 30.5 L of solution per kg of fruit in the tank;[1] 2.68 kg per plant from beverage cans[5] |
| Kai choy, herbs | Commercial covered tanks | Named as short-term crops that suit the lettuce tanks[1] |
Fruiting crops are covered on Kratky systems for tomatoes and cucumbers; crop choice for home growers is covered in crops tested with the Kratky method.
Evidence for the air space
The central claim of the method is that roots in the moist air above the solution supply the oxygen an unaerated tank lacks. Kratky's papers test it by comparing covers held above the solution with covers floating on it:
- Lettuce yielded 19 percent more by the suspended pot method than on a raft floating on a shallow, receding 7.6 cm of unaerated solution.[3]
- In the 2008 float-support trials, 'Jericho' romaine in Hawaii yielded significantly less on continuously floating boards and 8 cm supports than on a fixed cover or 10 and 12 cm supports.[3]
- Transplanted watercress yielded 17 and 22 percent more over 12 weeks under a suspended cover than under a floating cover, with more vigorous roots in the moist air zone.[6]
The evidence is not one-sided. Direct-seeded watercress yielded about the same under both covers at Volcano, and in a one-year trial at Mealani the floating cover yielded 7 percent more.[6] Kratky concluded that watercress may be grown with either cover.[6]
Limits found in the research
- Crop size. The 4-liter bottle suits only short crops that need less than 4 liters of water in their lifespan.[1]
- Fruiting crops. Tomatoes need 25 to 40 liters of water per kilogram of fruit, and Kratky judged the cost of tanks that large made fill-once tomatoes "an academic curiosity except in special situations".[1]
- Rain. Rain raises the solution level and submerges the air roots, so commercial tanks sit under plastic-covered rain shelters.[4]
- Long-running solutions. For ratoon watercress harvested monthly, yields were 49 percent higher after six months when the solution was fully changed every two months instead of only topped off.[6]
- Mosquitoes. Still solution can breed mosquitoes; screens, salt-tolerant fish and Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis are the controls in the research.[2]
See also
References
- Kratky, B.A. (2004). "A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method." Acta Horticulturae 648: 83–89. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A., G.T. Maehira, E.J. Magno, M.D. Orzolek and W.J. Lamont (2008). "Growing lettuce by a float-support non-circulating hydroponic method in Hawaii and Pennsylvania." Proceedings of the 34th National Agricultural Plastics Congress. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2010). A Suspended Net-Pot, Non-Circulating Hydroponic Method for Commercial Production of Leafy, Romaine, and Semi-Head Lettuce. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-1. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A., G.T. Maehira, R.J. Cupples and C.C. Bernabe (2005). "Non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing tomatoes." Proceedings of the National Agricultural Plastics Congress 32: 31–36. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2015). Growing Direct-Seeded Watercress by Two Non-Circulating Hydroponic Methods. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-7. PDF.
- University of Hawaii at Mānoa (April 4, 2008). "UH Manoa researcher wins national agricultural award for hydroponics study." Article.
- Kratky, B.A. Bernard A. Kratky Bio-Bibliography. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Tropical Plant and Soil Sciences Department. PDF.
- da Silva, W.A.V., G. de Faria, O. Guedes Filho and R.B. Mazzini-Guedes (2025). "Hydroponic lettuce cultivated under different electrical conductivities in the Kratky method." Bragantia. doi:10.1590/1678-4499.20250076.
- Gumisiriza, M.S., P. Ndakidemi and E. Mbega (2022). "A simplified non-greenhouse hydroponic system for small-scale soilless urban vegetable farming." MethodsX 9: 101882. doi:10.1016/j.mex.2022.101882.