Kratky float-support method
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky system designs.
| Researchers | B.A. Kratky, G.T. Maehira, E.J. Magno (Hawaii); M.D. Orzolek, W.J. Lamont (Penn State)[1] |
|---|---|
| Trial sites | Volcano, Hawaii, and State College, Pennsylvania[1] |
| Tank | Raceway 14 cm deep, about 1.2 m wide[2] |
| Cover | Extruded polystyrene boards, 61 × 122 cm, 12 plants each[2] |
| Supports | Two 10 cm plastic pipes, 0.9 m apart[2] |
| Air gap at harvest | 3 to 9 cm[2] |
| Award | American Society for Plasticulture Best Paper Award, 2008[3] |
The Kratky float-support method is a version of the Kratky method in which the plant board floats on the nutrient solution at planting and then comes to rest on pipes laid on the tank floor as the level falls, which opens the moist air space the roots need.[2] It combines the labor savings of floating rafts, which can be pushed along a raceway to a harvest station, with the single fill of solution and the air gap of the covered tank method.[1] The 2008 study of the method won the American Society for Plasticulture's Best Paper Award.[3]
Why a support is needed
A raft that floats for the whole crop leaves no air space between the board and the solution. In Kratky's experiments, a continuously floating cover with no support cut yields by up to 23 percent compared with a cover held by the tank frame.[2] An earlier Hawaii trial found lettuce yielded 19 percent more in the suspended pot method than on a raft floating on a shallow 7.6 cm depth of non-aerated solution, but only 7 percent less when the board floated first and then rested on a 5 cm support.[1] The float-support design adds a taller support and a deeper tank to close that gap.
Design
- Raceway. A long rectangular tank 14 cm deep with an inside width of about 1.25 m, made by draping 0.15 mm polyethylene over a lumber frame on level ground. The 2008 trial tanks measured 1.22 m by 7.32 m inside.[2][1]
- Supports. Two parallel 10 cm plastic pipes, 0.9 m apart on the tank floor, weighted with zip-lock bags of pebbles so they do not float.[2]
- Boards. Extruded polystyrene, 1.3 or 2.5 cm thick and 61 × 122 cm, with holes for 5 cm net pots in a staggered 20 × 30 cm pattern. Expanded polystyrene beadboard is not suitable: it has air pockets and can become waterlogged and covered with algae.[2]
- Planting. Seedlings one to two weeks old go into net pots of peat-perlite medium. The boards float at first because the solution is deeper than the pipes, then settle on the pipes as water is lost to evaporation and transpiration.[2]
2008 trial results
The 2008 study compared a fixed cover, a continuously floating cover, and boards that came to rest on 8, 10 or 12 cm pipes, with three lettuce types at each site.[1]
| Cover | 'Red Sails' (leafy) | 'Jericho' (romaine) | 'Green Mignonette' (semi-head) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed, supported by frame | 398 | 551 | 303 |
| Continuously floating | 350 | 398 | 304 |
| Float-support, 8 cm pipe | 353 | 409 | 311 |
| Float-support, 10 cm pipe | 386 | 515 | 321 |
| Float-support, 12 cm pipe | 388 | 586 | 307 |
In Pennsylvania, yields of all three cultivars ('Red Sails', 'Green Forest' romaine and 'Adriana' semi-head) were statistically similar across every treatment. In Hawaii the same was true for the leafy and semi-head types, but 'Jericho' romaine yielded significantly less on the floating and 8 cm treatments than on the fixed cover and the 10 and 12 cm supports.[1] The authors linked this to large romaine heads with a high oxygen demand growing on the thinner 1.3 cm Hawaii boards, which left too little moist-air root zone unless the board was held up.[1] Kratky's 2009 summary reports that yields from 14 cm tanks with 10 cm supports were always as good as from the fixed-cover method.[2]
Water and nutrient use
Water use ranged from 18 to 32 liters per kilogram of lettuce in the warmer, windier Pennsylvania tunnel and only 11 to 14 liters per kilogram in Hawaii; most water was lost through transpiration in the last two weeks.[1] In Pennsylvania the crops used 0.70 g of nitrogen per plant, or 3.3 g per kilogram of lettuce, and about one-sixth of the applied nutrients remained at the end. Topping off the leftover solution worked for at least three crops in a row before a full drain was needed.[1] The boards also insulated the solution: in Pennsylvania its temperature stayed between 15 and 24 °C and rarely varied more than 2 °C a day, while the tunnel air ranged from 1 to 35 °C.[1]
Harvest
At harvest the raceway is filled with water so the boards float again. A pair of strings tied to the last board lets the whole raft be pulled to the collection end, where boards are lifted onto a platform for cutting. Net pots are removed and cleaned, boards are washed and replanted, stock solutions are added to the tank, and the new boards are floated back.[2] In the trials, net pots were harder to remove from boards that had floated for the whole crop or rested on 8 cm pipes, because roots stuck to the board's underside.[1]
See also
- Kratky system designs
- Kratky covered tank method
- Kratky capillary tube method
- History of the Kratky method
References
- Kratky, B.A., G.T. Maehira, E.J. Magno, M.D. Orzolek and W.J. Lamont (2008). "Growing lettuce by a float-support non-circulating hydroponic method in Hawaii and Pennsylvania." Proceedings of the 34th National Agricultural Plastics Congress. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
- University of Hawaii at Mānoa (April 4, 2008). "UH Manoa researcher wins national agricultural award for hydroponics study." Article.