Rain shelters in Kratky's research
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky method research.
| What | Frames covered with clear plastic on top, often screened on the sides[1] |
|---|---|
| Power | Usually none; cooled passively[1] |
| Common shape | Quonset-style tunnels and arches[1] |
| Main paper | Kratky 2006, National Agricultural Plastics Congress[1] |
| Why Kratky tanks need them | Rain raises the solution and submerges the air roots[2] |
Rain shelters are the plastic-roofed structures that Bernard Kratky's commercial non-circulating tanks stand in. A Kratky lettuce tank cannot take rain: extra water raises the solution level and drowns the oxygen roots in the air space, so the 2010 grower bulletin puts tanks in plastic-covered rain shelters or screened greenhouses and recommends outdoor growing only in dry places.[2] Kratky studied these structures for decades before and alongside his hydroponics work, and summarized that research in a 2006 paper on plastic-covered rain shelters for the tropics.[1]
Why the tropics need rain shelters
Many tropical places receive 80 to 500 cm of rain a year. Rain raises disease levels, washes off pesticides, causes cracking and splitting in tomatoes, and leaches nitrogen and potassium from the root zone; it also makes work hard to schedule. A rain shelter reduces all of these, and Kratky argued it can turn cheap, rainy land with an otherwise good climate into productive farmland.[1] In Hawaii's Mountain View area, at a favorable elevation but with 350 to 500 cm of rain a year, open-field vegetables faced "insurmountable" problems.[1]
Rain and Kratky's hydroponic systems
- Lettuce tanks. Commercial tanks are normally grown in screened, plastic-covered rain shelters or greenhouses.[3] One design Kratky describes covers lettuce tanks 1.2 to 1.8 m wide with an arched shelter whose screened sides are held down by a sand-filled pipe that lifts for access.[1]
- Tomatoes. With 158 cm of rain during one crop and no rain protection, salable tomato yields fell by 100 percent in hydroponic pots and 55 percent in tanks, compared with plots under a row cover.[1]
- Cucumbers. The trash-container method can stand outdoors, because cucumbers tolerate rain fairly well and the sloping lid sheds most of it.[4]
- Watercress. Watercress tolerates rain entering its tanks, so rain shelters are not mandatory, though rain dilutes the solution.[5] See the Kratky watercress method.
Structures and coverings
- Frames. Lumber and metal are most common; PVC pipe, bamboo and guava wood have also been used. Arched and Quonset shapes are most common, but gable and temporary tent structures are also used.[1]
- Coverings. Use only UV-stabilized film made for greenhouses; construction-grade polyethylene fails within six months in sunlight. Film fits arched frames snugly but flaps on straight members unless held with battens. Painting frame members white reduces heat build-up that ages the plastic.[1]
- Low-cost tunnels. Tunnels 4.4 m wide built from 1.9 cm Schedule 40 PVC pipe and 6-mil polyethylene suit non-windy sites. They need a 2.3 m center support; a 9.2 m wide PVC structure failed because even moderate wind bent the pipes too far.[1]
- Row covers. Shelters 0.8 m wide over single tomato rows, under 89 cm of rain, gave 13 and 19 percent more salable fruit and 31 and 95 percent more grade 1 fruit than unprotected plots, for two cultivars.[1]
Passive cooling
Shelters trap heat, which helps warm-season crops at cool high elevations and hurts many crops in warm lowlands.[1] At Volcano, Hawaii (1,200 m), air in rain shelters was commonly at least 10 °C warmer than outside for 4 to 8 hours around midday, which made tomato growing possible there.[1] Kratky's cooling measures, none needing power:[1]
- Air exchange, the most common method: about one air change per minute kept a tomato shelter 5.6 °C above outside, or 0.4 changes per minute with misting. Fine end screens restrict airflow sharply.
- Reflective surfaces, such as white walkway covers, white mulch, white hydroponic tank covers and white-painted posts.
- Tall, narrow and top-vented structures, with grassy space between them; large gutter-connected complexes overheat.
- Orientation to the prevailing wind, which in the tropics may matter more than orientation for light.
Growing under a rain shelter
- Salinity. Growers used to applying extra fertilizer against rain leaching can raise soil salinity under a shelter; sluggish growth with lush plants under a roof leak is a sign to test.[1]
- Pollination may be poor in enclosed, screened shelters; parthenocarpic cucumbers or shaking tomato trusses help.[1]
- Transplanting raises output: 14-day-old lettuce transplants with a 28-day grow-out give 50 percent more crops than a 42-day direct-seeded crop.[1]
- Pests and disease. Small, separate shelters isolate problems; keep one crop of one age per shelter and shorten time in the shelter. Two-cluster tomatoes at double density gave 47 percent more salable fruit per square meter per day than eight-cluster plants and needed 347 g of pesticide per 1,000 kg of fruit instead of 708 g.[1]
- Onions. Temporary fiberglass shelters cut field spoilage of onions to 25 percent from 69 percent.[1]
Volcanic acid rain
On the Kona side of the island of Hawaii, volcanic haze ("vog") from Kīlauea, about 75 km away, brought acidic rain (pH 4.0 to 4.4) containing organic pollutants. Field tomatoes there suffered blossom drop, poor fruit set and small, almost seedless fruit, with no salable yield. Under a simple polyethylene-covered rain shelter on a guava-stick frame, plants grew normally and produced 5 kg of fruit each.[1] Kratky first reported the damage in a 1974 paper on volcanic air pollution and tomatoes.[1]
See also
References
- Kratky, B.A. (2006). "Plastic-covered rainshelters for vegetable production in the tropics." Proceedings of the 33rd National Agricultural Plastics Congress. American Society for Plasticulture. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2010). A Suspended Net-Pot, Non-Circulating Hydroponic Method for Commercial Production of Leafy, Romaine, and Semi-Head Lettuce. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-1. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2004). "A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method." Acta Horticulturae 648: 83–89. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2015). Growing Direct-Seeded Watercress by Two Non-Circulating Hydroponic Methods. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-7. PDF.