Mosquito control research in Kratky tanks
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky method research.
| Pest | Asian tiger mosquito, Aedes albopictus[1] |
|---|---|
| Researchers | S.C. Furutani and L. Arita-Tsutsumi (University of Hawaii at Hilo), with B.A. Kratky[1][3] |
| Published | 2001 and 2005, Proceedings of the Hawaiian Entomological Society[1][3] |
| Treatments tested | Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis (Bti), methoprene, Pyronyl Crop Spray[1][3] |
| Crop | Lettuce[1] |
Mosquito control in non-circulating hydroponics became a research subject in Hawaii once several large commercial non-circulating lettuce farms had been established there by 2001: their still, nutrient-rich water proved an ideal breeding site for the Asian tiger mosquito.[1][3] The mosquitoes did not harm the crop but were a serious nuisance to farm workers, and because Hawaii's hydroponic lettuce was sold as "pesticide-free", ordinary insecticides were not an option.[1] Three University of Hawaii studies tested alternatives in the nutrient solution, and Kratky's own papers describe physical controls.[4]
Note: these are research results, not product advice. The 2001 study notes that one treatment it tested was not labeled for commercial use on lettuce. Pesticide labels and registrations change; growers should follow the current label and local rules.[1]
Why Kratky tanks breed mosquitoes
The Asian tiger mosquito lays eggs in water, where larvae and pupae develop before adults emerge; females then need a blood meal to produce eggs. The stagnant, nutrient-rich solution of a non-circulating tank suits the larvae, and the workers tending the plants supply the blood meals.[1] Growers usually screen their greenhouses against pests, so once the mosquito gets inside, its population can rise very quickly. The 2005 study also cites the appearance of dengue fever and West Nile disease in Hawaii as added reasons to control this mosquito.[3] Circulated or aerated hydroponic systems do not usually have this problem.[3]
Physical controls in Kratky's papers
- Tight covers. A snugly fitting plant holder in the lid of a cucumber container helps keep mosquitoes out.[5]
- A screen in the tank. A screen draped in the tank below the starting solution level traps newly hatched mosquitoes once the level falls below it.[4]
- Screened structures. Screens on greenhouse sides give some control.[4]
- Fish. Salt-tolerant fish in the tanks.[4]
- Climate. Cool air or dry, windy conditions discourage mosquito populations.[4]
Bti and methoprene (2001)
Furutani and Arita-Tsutsumi tested Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis (Bti), a bacterial larvicide, and methoprene, an insect growth regulator, in commercial-scale lettuce tanks 2.44 m long, 1.22 m wide and 19 cm deep.[1] Neither counted as a pesticide for the "pesticide-free" label.[1]
- Both reduced mosquito larvae and pupae for the whole 4 to 5 week lettuce crop compared with untreated tanks.[1]
- Both also reduced lettuce head weight and root growth.[1]
- Leaf lettuces 'Red Sails' and 'Green Ice' tolerated Bti better than 'Manoa'.[1]
- Lowering the Bti granule rate from 1.04 to 0.54 g/m² improved head weight and root growth of 'Manoa'.[1]
The treatments were not replicated, because the tanks were large and greenhouse space was limited.[1]
Split Bti application (2001)
A follow-up note tested the Bti granules in two non-circulating systems, sub-irrigated pots and Kratky's suspended forestry tubes, with 'Manoa' lettuce.[2] Single applications of 1.08 and 0.54 g/m² greatly reduced larvae and pupae but again cut head weight and root growth. When the 0.54 g/m² dose was split into two 0.27 g/m² applications two weeks apart, mosquitoes were still controlled through the crop and head weight was not significantly affected.[2] This experiment was also unreplicated.[2]
Pyronyl Crop Spray (2005)
With Kratky as co-author, the 2005 study tested Pyronyl Crop Spray, a mix of 6 percent pyrethrins and 60 percent piperonyl butoxide that at the time was labeled for hydroponically grown vegetables and as a water treatment against aquatic fly larvae.[3]
- In jars of larvae, 99 percent were dead after an average of 35.8 hours at 1.0 ppm and 2.3 hours at 2.0 ppm. At 0.25 ppm and below, kill times were similar to untreated water, over 200 hours.[3]
- Lettuce grown for five weeks in solution with 1.25, 2.5 or 5.0 ppm showed no loss of head weight; root weight was unaffected at the two lower rates and slightly reduced at 5.0 ppm.[3]
- The authors noted that plants in stagnant solution had proven very sensitive to petroleum compounds added to it, which is why phytotoxicity was tested.[3]
Summary of the studies
| Treatment | Mosquito control | Effect on lettuce |
|---|---|---|
| Methoprene (2001) | Yes, whole crop | Severely reduced head and root weight[2] |
| Bti, single dose (2001) | Yes, whole crop | Reduced head and root weight; cultivars differed[1] |
| Bti, split dose (2001) | Yes, whole crop | Head weight not significantly affected[2] |
| Pyronyl, 1–2 ppm (2005) | Yes, in lab tests | No head weight loss up to 5 ppm[3] |
See also
References
- Furutani, S.C. and L. Arita-Tsutsumi (2001). "Use of Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis and methoprene to control Asian tiger mosquito, Aedes albopictus (Skuse) (Diptera: Culicidae), in non-circulating hydroponics tanks." Proceedings of the Hawaiian Entomological Society 35: 103–109. ScholarSpace.
- Furutani, S.C. and L. Arita-Tsutsumi (2001). "Split-application of Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis to control Asian tiger mosquito … without reducing lettuce head weight in non-circulating hydroponics." Proceedings of the Hawaiian Entomological Society 35: 115–118. ScholarSpace.
- Furutani, S.C., L. Arita-Tsutsumi and B.A. Kratky (2005). "Pyronyl crop spray effective in controlling larvae of the Asian tiger mosquito … in non-circulating hydroponic nutrient solution." Proceedings of the Hawaiian Entomological Society 37: 27–31. ScholarSpace.
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A. (2004). "A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method." Acta Horticulturae 648: 83–89. PDF.