Kratky systems for tomatoes and cucumbers
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky system designs.
| Cucumber container | 100–130 L plastic trash container, or 208 L lined barrel[1] |
|---|---|
| Cucumber solution | EC 2.0 to 2.5 mS, filled to within 2 cm of the top[1] |
| Cucumber crop | About 80 days[1] |
| Tomato fill-once tank | 757 L for 12 plants[1] |
| Tomato water need | 25 to 40 L per kg of fruit[1] |
Kratky systems for tomatoes and cucumbers are the large-container versions of the Kratky method that Dr. Bernard Kratky and his colleagues tested for long-season fruiting crops.[1] Because these crops use far more water than lettuce, a fill-once container has to be very large: one cucumber plant gets a 100 to 130 liter trash container, and twelve tomato plants needed a 757 liter tank.[1] For tomatoes, Kratky's later work kept a shallow level topped up by float valves instead.[2]
Cucumbers in a trash container
Cucumbers can be grown one plant to a large plastic trash container of 100 to 130 liters, or in 208 liter metal barrels with plastic liners.[1] The containers can stand outdoors, because cucumbers tolerate rain fairly well and the sloping lid sheds most of it.[1]
- Fill the container with water to within 2 cm of the top and add hydroponic fertilizer to an EC of 2.0 to 2.5 mS. Nothing more is added.[1]
- Use a tapered forestry tube 3.8 cm across and 21 cm long. Drill six or more 5 mm holes in its sides so roots can leave through the sides as well as the bottom. Fill it with moist medium without packing it tight, and plant one seed.[1]
- Cut a 3.8 cm hole in the lid about 8 cm from the edge. The tube should fit snugly, which also keeps mosquitoes out. Its lower 2 to 8 cm sits in the solution and the medium is wetted by capillary action.[1]
- Once roots have emerged, do not lift the lid, and do not add water or fertilizer: raising the level typically injures the plant.[1]
The crop usually ends soon after less than 10 percent of the solution remains, at about 80 days. In a 208 liter barrel the level finished more than 70 cm below the seedling container, with no mechanical help. Yields above 7 kg per 120 liter container were obtained in cool weather, but Kratky gave half of that as a more normal expectation.[1] A permanent trellis can stay in place, and a weed mat under the containers controls weeds.[1]
Tomatoes in a fill-once tank
Kratky built a tank 0.6 m wide, 3.6 m long and 0.4 m high and filled it with 757 liters of solution at EC 1.5 mS. Twelve tomato plants in 3.8 × 7.6 cm net pots were set in the cover and harvested until the solution ran out. They gave 24.79 kg of salable fruit, or 30.5 liters of solution per kilogram.[1] A screen placed 10 cm below the cover encouraged fine roots and helped anchor the plants.[1]
Since tomatoes typically need 25 to 40 liters of water per kilogram of fruit, a commercial version would need a tank several times larger. Kratky judged that the cost limited this "fill it and forget it" method to "an academic curiosity except in special situations".[1]
Tomatoes with a maintained level
Kratky's 2005 tomato trials kept the solution non-circulating and unaerated but no longer fill-once: the level started at 7.5 cm, was lowered below 5 cm as roots left the containers, and was then held there. The EC was 1.0 mS until fruit set and 1.5 to 2.5 mS after.[2]
| Container | Result |
|---|---|
| 0.35 L recycled aluminum beverage cans, slit, resting on the tank floor | 'Big Beef' gave 2.68 kg per plant over a 72-day harvest |
| 70 ml net pots in a polystyrene cover | Similar to cans in one trial, lower in another; wind moved the loose cover |
| 10 cm pots of perlite on 5 cm upside-down nursery trays | Significantly higher than cans in two trials; the tray raised the roots into moist air and gave them a grid to anchor to |
| 7.6 L pots sub-irrigated by microtubes from a float-valve sump | Worked under a rain shelter, but roots sometimes blocked the tubes and killed plants |
Beverage cans needed less than 3 percent of the growing medium of the bag culture Kratky had used before.[2]
Mosquitoes and rain
Still solution can breed mosquitoes, especially at warm low elevations. In the 2005 work, window screen laid over the nursery trays, above the maintained level, trapped newly hatched mosquitoes below it.[2] Rain was the other limit: with 158 cm of rain during one crop, tomatoes under a simple polyethylene rain shelter yielded 1.75 kg of salable fruit, against 0.78 kg for unprotected plants, and the unprotected sub-irrigated pots gave no salable yield.[2] Other mosquito controls in Kratky's work include salt-tolerant fish and Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis.[1]
Which crops suit the method best is covered in crops tested with the Kratky method.
See also
- Kratky system designs
- Kratky bottle method
- Kratky covered tank method
- Crops tested with the Kratky method
Further reading
Practical guides from related Kratky sites. These are not sources for the facts on this page.
- How to set up a Kratky tomato system, Kratky Tomatoes
- Kratky container size for cucumbers, Kratky Cucumbers
References
- Kratky, B.A. (2004). "A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method." Acta Horticulturae 648: 83–89. PDF.
- Kratky, B.A., G.T. Maehira, R.J. Cupples and C.C. Bernabe (2005). "Non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing tomatoes." Proceedings of the National Agricultural Plastics Congress 32: 31–36. PDF.