Kratky method studies by other researchers
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky method research.
Kratky method studies by other researchers are trials by researchers other than Bernard Kratky that grow crops in passive, non-circulating hydroponic systems of his design. Most use the method as a simple, low-cost test bed for lettuce, then vary one thing: nutrient strength, nitrogen rate, growing medium, an organic additive, a beneficial bacterium or the light source.[2][3][6] Others test the method itself as a way to grow food cheaply in cities.[7] Papers describe these systems as "non-circulating", "static" or simply "Kratky" hydroponics.[4][5]
Summary of studies
| Year | Authors | Tested | Main finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Kobayashi, Amore and Lazaro[1] | Blue LEDs, red LEDs and fluorescent light on miniature lettuce | No difference in shoot dry weight or plant height |
| 2015 | Arancon, Schaffer and Converse[2] | Coconut husk and sphagnum moss plugs vs. forestry tubes of peat mix | Higher growth and yield in coconut husk and moss |
| 2016 | Mahlangu, Maboko, Sivakumar, Soundy and Jifon[3] | Seven nitrogen rates, 0 to 180 mg/L | Yield unaffected; quality peaked at 100 to 120 mg/L N |
| 2019 | Arancon, Owens and Converse[4] | Vermicompost tea with reduced-strength nutrient solution | Higher lettuce and tomato yields at reduced nutrient strength |
| 2022 | Sebring, Duiker, Berghage, Regan, Lambert and Bryant[5] | Inoculation with Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus at seven nitrogen rates | Up to 14.8 percent more shoot growth |
| 2022 | Gumisiriza, Ndakidemi and Mbega[7] | A low-tech, 60-plant unit outside a greenhouse, Uganda | Profitable, with a payback of about 8 months |
| 2023 | Gumisiriza, Ndakidemi, Nampijja and Mbega[8] | Red and green leaf lettuce, hydroponic vs. soil, Uganda | Leaf number comparable to soil-grown lettuce |
| 2025 | da Silva, de Faria, Guedes Filho and Mazzini-Guedes[6] | Four solution EC levels, winter and summer, Brazil | Best EC 2.3 to 2.6 mS/cm in winter, 2.8 to 3.3 in summer |
Nutrient strength and nitrogen
Electrical conductivity (Brazil, 2025). Da Silva and colleagues noted that the Kratky method is little studied in Brazil and tested 'Crespa Itapuã 401 Super' lettuce at solution EC levels of 0.6, 1.5, 2.5 and 3.5 mS/cm, with 13 plants per level, in winter and summer.[6] Lettuce was harvested 45 days after transplanting in winter and 31 days in summer. The ideal EC was 2.3 to 2.6 mS/cm in winter and 2.8 to 3.3 mS/cm in summer, and the authors concluded the method suits this cultivar in both seasons.[6] These optimums are higher than the EC of about 1.5 mS that Kratky used for lettuce in Hawaii.[9]
Nitrogen rate (2016). Mahlangu and colleagues grew leafy lettuce in winter in a non-circulating system at seven nitrogen concentrations from 0 to 180 mg/L, supplied as ammonium nitrate.[3] Nitrogen rate had no significant effect on leaf or root fresh and dry mass, leaf number or leaf area. Leaf ascorbic acid, total phenolics and antioxidant capacity peaked at 100 and 120 mg/L, while chlorophyll rose steadily with nitrogen. The authors suggested 100 to 120 mg/L as sufficient for growth, yield and quality.[3]
Growing media
Arancon, Schaffer and Converse (2015) compared two ways of potting lettuce in a Kratky-type tank: plugs of coconut husk and sphagnum moss, and plastic forestry tubes filled with a peat-based mix.[2] Their setup followed Kratky's tank design closely: two-week-old seedlings in 5 cm holes at 20 × 30 cm in polystyrene bead boards over tanks 0.6 m wide, 1.2 m long and 25 cm deep, with a nutrient solution of Chem-Gro fertilizer, calcium nitrate and magnesium sulfate.[2] Romaine 'Ridgeline' and buttercrunch 'UH Manoa' both grew and yielded significantly more in the coconut husk and moss plugs, which the authors attributed to their greater water-holding capacity and better root growth.[2]
Organic and biological additives
Vermicompost tea (2019). Arancon, Owens and Converse added teas made from food-waste vermicompost to static hydroponic systems, at 1.6 and 3.2 percent for lettuce and 0.14 to 0.56 percent for tomatoes.[4] The teas significantly increased lettuce yields when the nutrient solution was cut to 25 or 50 percent of full strength, and lower rates increased tomato yields in a 50 percent solution. The authors attributed the effect to trace plant hormones and humic acids in the teas.[4]
Nitrogen-fixing bacteria (2022). Sebring and colleagues grew 'Black Seeded Simpson' and 'Bibb/Limestone' lettuce in "Kratky jars" in a growth chamber, with or without the bacterium Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus, across seven nitrogen rates from 37.5 to 172.5 mg/L.[5] Inoculated 'Black Seeded Simpson' produced 14.8 percent more shoot biomass at a slightly deficient 105 mg/L, and 'Bibb/Limestone' averaged 10.9 percent more. Lower nitrogen density in inoculated leaves pointed to better nitrogen use efficiency.[5]
Lighting
Kobayashi, Amore and Lazaro (2013) grew miniature 'Tom Thumb' butterhead lettuce in net pots over containers of nutrient solution, a non-circulating system, under blue LEDs, red LEDs or fluorescent lights in a lab.[1] Shoot dry weight and plant height did not differ significantly. Fluorescent light gave more root dry weight than either LED, and blue LEDs and fluorescent light gave more leaf chlorophyll than red LEDs.[1]
Low-cost and urban growing
Gumisiriza, Ndakidemi and Mbega (2022) designed a Kratky unit for 60 leafy vegetables from low-cost, low-tech materials, for use outside a greenhouse, and tested it, including its economics, with lettuce on an urban farm near Kampala, Uganda.[7] They reported a net present value of US$16.37, an internal rate of return of 12.57 percent, a profitability index of 1.1 and a payback period of about 8 months, or four cropping seasons, and concluded the system could profitably improve urban food production in developing countries.[7]
In a follow-up study, the same group compared red and green leaf lettuce grown in the system with soil-grown lettuce. Dry matter, fresh weight and root length differed significantly between the two, but based on leaf number, "the key edible part", the authors judged that hydroponics can perform as well as conventional farming.[8]
Extension and teaching
The method has also moved into extension publishing outside Hawaii. A 2025 University of Florida EDIS publication by Hannah Wooten presents "set it and forget it" hydroponic lettuce as a simple, affordable introductory method, especially well suited to classroom experiments.[10] Kratky had promoted the bottle method to schools for the same reason: it needs no weekend watering.[9]
What the later studies add
- New climates. Kratky's trials were in Hawaii and one Pennsylvania season. The studies here add Brazil's winter and summer seasons, non-greenhouse urban growing, and growth-chamber and lab conditions.[1][5][6][7]
- Nutrient detail. Kratky gave working recipes; the later studies measure responses to EC and nitrogen rate.[3][6]
- Lettuce still dominates. Every study on this page grew lettuce; only one also grew tomatoes.[4]
- No head-to-head test. None of the studies on this page compares a Kratky system directly with a circulating system such as NFT or aerated deep water culture.
For Kratky's own trials, see publications on the Kratky method.
See also
References
- Kobayashi, K.D., T. Amore and M. Lazaro (2013). "Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) for miniature hydroponic lettuce." Optics and Photonics Journal 3(1): 74–77. doi:10.4236/opj.2013.31012.
- Arancon, N.Q., N. Schaffer and C.E. Converse (2015). "Effects of coconut husk and sphagnum moss-based media on growth and yield of romaine and buttercrunch lettuce (Lactuca sativa) in a non-circulating hydroponics system." Journal of Plant Nutrition 38(8): 1218–1230. doi:10.1080/01904167.2014.983117.
- Mahlangu, R.I.S., M.M. Maboko, D. Sivakumar, P. Soundy and J. Jifon (2016). "Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) growth, yield and quality response to nitrogen fertilization in a non-circulating hydroponic system." Journal of Plant Nutrition 39(12): 1766–1775. doi:10.1080/01904167.2016.1187739.
- Arancon, N.Q., J.D. Owens and C. Converse (2019). "The effects of vermicompost tea on the growth and yield of lettuce and tomato in a non-circulating hydroponics system." Journal of Plant Nutrition 42(19): 2447–2458. doi:10.1080/01904167.2019.1655049.
- Sebring, R.L., S.W. Duiker, R.D. Berghage, J.M. Regan, J.D. Lambert and R.B. Bryant (2022). "Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus inoculation of two lettuce cultivars affects leaf and root growth under hydroponic conditions." Applied Sciences 12(3): 1585. doi:10.3390/app12031585.
- da Silva, W.A.V., G. de Faria, O. Guedes Filho and R.B. Mazzini-Guedes (2025). "Hydroponic lettuce cultivated under different electrical conductivities in the Kratky method." Bragantia 84: e20250076. doi:10.1590/1678-4499.20250076.
- Gumisiriza, M.S., P.A. Ndakidemi and E.R. Mbega (2022). "A simplified non-greenhouse hydroponic system for small-scale soilless urban vegetable farming." MethodsX 9: 101882. doi:10.1016/j.mex.2022.101882.
- Gumisiriza, M.S., P.A. Ndakidemi, Z. Nampijja and E.R. Mbega (2023). "Soilless urban gardening as a post covid-19 food security salvage technology: a study on the physiognomic response of lettuce to hydroponics in Uganda." Scientific African 20: e01643. doi:10.1016/j.sciaf.2023.e01643.
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
- Wooten, H. (2025). "'Set it and forget it' hydroponic lettuce." EDIS 2025(1). University of Florida IFAS Extension. doi:10.32473/edis-hs1488-2025.