Kratky method water use and nutrient use

From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics

Part of Kratky method research.

Water use at a glance
Lettuce, Hawaii11 to 14 L per kg[3]
Lettuce, Pennsylvania18 to 32 L per kg[3]
Lettuce per plantAbout 3 to 6 L[4]
Tomatoes25 to 40 L per kg of fruit[2]
Nitrogen, lettuce3.3 g per kg of lettuce[3]

Kratky method water use is low: in Kratky's lettuce trials a crop typically used less than 20 liters of water per kilogram of lettuce, and as little as 11 liters per kilogram was recorded.[4] Most of that water leaves through the plants, because the cover leaves very little solution surface open to evaporation.[3] Fruiting crops are a different matter: tomatoes typically need 25 to 40 liters of water per kilogram of fruit, which is why they need very large tanks.[2] This page brings together the water and nutrient figures from Kratky's papers.

Lettuce

Lettuce water use reported by Kratky
SourceSystem and placeWater per kg of lettuce
Patent 5,385,589 (filed 1992)Capillary tube tank, Hawaii greenhouse14.4 L ('Green Ice'); 12.6 L ('Green Mignonette')[1]
Kratky et al. 2008Float-support and fixed-cover tanks, Volcano, Hawaii11 to 14 L[3]
Kratky et al. 2008Same designs in a high tunnel, State College, Pennsylvania18 to 32 L[3]
Kratky 2009Summary of the methodUnder 20 L common; 11 L lowest[4]
Kratky 2010 (VC-1)Covered tank, for growersUnder 3 gal per lb common; 1.3 gal per lb lowest[5]

One gallon per pound is about 8.3 liters per kilogram, so the bulletin's 1.3 gallons per pound matches the 11 liters per kilogram in the 2009 paper, and its 3 gallons per pound is about 25 liters per kilogram.

The 2008 Pennsylvania trial shows how much the weather moves the figure. Its six plantings ran from June to October 2007:[3]

Pennsylvania plantings, 2007, averaged over treatments and cultivars[3]
ReplicateTransplantedHarvestedDaysAverage head (g)Water (L per kg)
1June 22July 313922823
2July 9August 72924520
3July 31August 282816932
4August 7September 113523218
5August 28October 23523623
6September 11October 163515419

The least efficient crop was the July 31 to August 28 planting. Replicates 1, 3 and 5, on the side of the tunnel facing the prevailing winds, used more water than replicates 2, 4 and 6 on the calmer side. The Hawaii site, at higher elevation, was cooler and less windy.[3]

Solution per plant

  • Bottle. In Hilo, a 200 g lettuce typically uses only about 3 to 4 liters of solution, which is why one plant fits a 4-liter bottle.[2]
  • Typical crop. Growers aim for 150 to 250 g heads, which use about 3 to 6 liters of solution per plant.[4]
  • Tank fill. The model system holds 4 to 8 liters of solution per plant at planting;[4] the commercial bulletin fills 1.5 to 2 gallons per plant, so a 50-plant tank holds 75 to 100 gallons.[5]

By harvest, the level in a covered lettuce tank has typically dropped 6 to 12 cm.[4]

Where the water goes

In the 2008 trials, the largest water loss was transpiration in the last two weeks of the crop, when the plants had the most leaves. Evaporation losses were minimal, because only the small openings of the net pots and the uncovered edges of the cover exposed the solution.[3] Lettuce follows its normal logarithmic growth pattern in these systems, growing very rapidly near maturity.[2]

Fruiting crops and watercress

Water use for other crops
CropFigure
Tomato, typical25 to 40 L of water per kg of fruit[2]
Tomato, 757 L fill-once tank12 plants gave 24.79 kg of salable fruit: 30.5 L of solution per kg[2]
CucumberOne plant per 100 to 130 L trash container, crop ending when less than 10 percent of the solution remains, at about 80 days[2]
WatercressUncovered non-circulating tanks used about 0.1 percent of the water of continuously flowing field production[6]

The tank sizes behind these figures are described on Kratky systems for tomatoes and cucumbers.

Nutrient use

The 2008 Pennsylvania crops received 752 g of nitrogen in their stock solutions, or 0.70 g per plant. That is 3.3 g of nitrogen per kilogram of lettuce, which the authors called an efficient use of nitrogen and the other nutrients.[3] After the final harvest, the leftover solution in each tank measured EC 1.7 to 2.5 mS, so about one-sixth of the applied nutrients were unused. Topping off the leftover solution worked for at least three crops in a row in those trials.[3]

Longer-running crops behave differently. For ratoon watercress harvested every month, total yields after six months were 49 percent higher when the solution was completely changed every two months than when it was only topped off; a later 13-month trial reported 88 percent.[6] Kratky's general rule for lettuce tanks is to drain and refill after every three crops or sooner.[4]

Salt build-up

Because water leaves through the plants and salts stay behind, impurities in the water concentrate as the tank empties:

  • Water starting at EC 0.2 mS from contaminants reaches 2.0 mS when only 10 percent of the solution remains.[2]
  • Water starting at EC 0.5 mS may reach 2.0 mS when 25 percent remains, which could lead to tipburn.[4]

In both examples the contaminant EC rises in step with the share of water used: a tenth left gives ten times the starting level, a quarter left gives four times. Kratky recommends rainwater where water quality is poor; otherwise deeper tanks reduce the concentration, and tanks must be emptied after each crop.[4]

See also

Further reading

Practical guides from related Kratky sites. These are not sources for the facts on this page.

References

  1. Kratky, B.A. "Non-circulating hydroponic plant growing system." U.S. Patent 5,385,589, filed August 5, 1992, issued January 31, 1995. Patent.
  2. Kratky, B.A. (2004). "A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method." Acta Horticulturae 648: 83–89. PDF.
  3. Kratky, B.A., G.T. Maehira, E.J. Magno, M.D. Orzolek and W.J. Lamont (2008). "Growing lettuce by a float-support non-circulating hydroponic method in Hawaii and Pennsylvania." Proceedings of the 34th National Agricultural Plastics Congress. PDF.
  4. Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.
  5. Kratky, B.A. (2010). A Suspended Net-Pot, Non-Circulating Hydroponic Method for Commercial Production of Leafy, Romaine, and Semi-Head Lettuce. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-1. PDF.
  6. Kratky, B.A. (2015). Growing Direct-Seeded Watercress by Two Non-Circulating Hydroponic Methods. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-7. PDF.