Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce (2009)
From Kratky Method Hydroponics, a reference on passive, non-circulating hydroponics
Part of Kratky method research.
| Author | B.A. Kratky, University of Hawaii CTAHR, Beaumont Agricultural Research Center, Hilo[1] |
|---|---|
| Published | 2009, Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72[1] |
| Proceedings | International Symposium on Soilless Culture and Hydroponics[1] |
| DOI | 10.17660/ActaHortic.2009.843.6 |
| Crop | Leafy, semi-head and small romaine lettuce[1] |
| Methods | 4-liter bottle; cover supported by the tank frame; float-support raceway[1] |
"Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce" is a 2009 paper by Bernard A. Kratky that describes three ways of growing lettuce without electricity, pumps or wicks, with all of the nutrient solution added before planting.[1] It appeared in Acta Horticulturae volume 843, the proceedings of the International Symposium on Soilless Culture and Hydroponics.[1] The paper is a description of methods drawn from Kratky's earlier trials rather than a report of one new experiment, and it is the main source for the three designs on this site.
The model system
The paper's model system is a covered tank filled with 4 to 8 liters of nutrient solution per plant before planting. Lettuce grows in containers, preferably tapered plastic net pots with slits, held by the cover so their lower part is in the solution.[1] Capillary action wets the whole growing medium, so the plants are watered automatically.[1]
As the plants grow, the solution level falls and leaves an expanding moist air space, kept humid by the cover. Following Imai (1987), the paper calls roots in that space "oxygen roots", whose main function is aeration, and roots in the solution "water and nutrient roots".[1] The level may stay the same or fall, but it should not be raised, "because submerging the oxygen roots will cause the plant to 'drown'".[1]
The three methods
| Method | Container | Starting solution | Crop time | Level drop by harvest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4-liter bottle | Darkened 4 L plastic bottle; net pot or forestry tube in the neck, lower 3 cm in solution | Water to within 4 cm of the top plus 5 g of granular hydroponic fertilizer | About 6 to 7 weeks from seeding | 15 to 25 cm |
| Cover supported by the tank frame | Polyethylene-lined lumber and plywood tank, 1.2 × 2.4 m; polystyrene cover with 5 cm net pots at 20 × 30 cm | Two stock solutions to EC 1.5 mS | About 5 weeks from transplanting | 6 to 12 cm |
| Float-support raceway | Raceway 14 cm deep, 1.25 m wide; extruded polystyrene boards resting on two 10 cm pipes | As for the tank method | About 30 to 40 days from transplanting | Air gap of 3 to 9 cm at harvest |
The paper gives uses for each scale. The bottle suits educators, who can set it up in one class period with "no need for weekend watering", gardeners on lanais and porches, and researchers testing nutrition or pesticides.[1] The tank and raceway methods are for commercial growers, normally under screened, plastic-covered rain shelters or greenhouses.[1]
Reported results
- Water use. Less than 20 liters of water per kilogram of lettuce is common, and 11 liters per kilogram has been recorded (citing Kratky et al., 2008).[1]
- Head size and solution per plant. Growers typically aim for 150 to 250 g heads, which use about 3 to 6 liters of solution per plant; in Hilo a 200 g lettuce typically used 3 to 4 liters.[1]
- Float-support yields. Yields from 14 cm tanks with 10 cm pipe supports were always as good as from the fixed-cover method, but this was not always true with 5 cm supports in an 8.9 cm tank.[1]
- No air space, lower yield. Where the cover floated for the whole crop with no support, no moist air space formed and yields fell by up to 23 percent compared with a frame-supported cover.[1]
- Draining. Some growers drain and refill tanks after each crop and others top off; as a general rule, tanks should be drained and refilled after every three crops or sooner.[1]
The water-use figures are compared with Kratky's other trials on Kratky method water use and nutrient use.
Other considerations
- Mosquitoes. Unaerated solution can breed mosquitoes. A screen draped in the tank below the starting level traps newly hatched mosquitoes once the solution drops below it. Other controls are greenhouse side screens, salt-tolerant fish, Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis toxins, and pesticides; cool, dry or windy conditions also discourage them.[1]
- Water quality. Salts concentrate as the solution is used. Water with an EC of 0.5 mS from contaminants may reach 2.0 mS when 25 percent of the solution remains, which could cause tipburn. Rainwater is recommended where water is poor; otherwise deeper tanks dilute the salts, and tanks must be emptied after each crop.[1]
- pH. Crops were usually completed without altering pH. If the solution becomes too acidic, dolomite in a nylon stocking can be hung in the tank until the pH normalizes. If it becomes too basic, ammonium sulfate acidifies it as plants take it up: one approach is a 12 g per liter stock added at the same rate as the other two stocks, with the pH checked after four days.[1]
Conclusions
The paper concludes that lettuce can be grown without electricity or pumps on a single application of water and nutrients, because the immersed base of each container wets the medium by capillary action and the falling solution then creates an expanding moist air space and root system.[1] It summarizes the three methods as a net pot in the neck of a 4-liter bottle, 5 cm net pots in a cover on the frame of a 14 cm tank, and a floating cover that comes to rest on 10 cm pipes as the solution recedes.[1]
Sources the paper cites
The paper's literature cited includes Kratky's 1993 HortTechnology paper, both patents, the HG-42 home garden kit, the 2004 and 2005 papers and the 2008 float-support study, plus Imai (1987) on oxygen roots, Jensen (2002) on deep-flow hydroponics and polystyrene boards, and Furutani and Arita-Tsutsumi (2001) on mosquito control.[1] Full details are in publications on the Kratky method.
See also
References
- Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF; ISHS record.