Kratky lettuce EC: the 2025 Brazil study

Part of Kratky research notes. Summarized in Kratky method studies by other researchers.

Study at a glance
AuthorsW.A.V. da Silva, G. de Faria, O. Guedes Filho, R.B. Mazzini-Guedes[1]
InstitutionUniversidade Federal do Paraná, Jandaia do Sul, Brazil[1]
JournalBragantia 84 (2025)[1]
CropLettuce 'Crespa Itapuã 401 Super'[1]
TreatmentsEC 0.6, 1.5, 2.5 and 3.5 mS/cm[1]
Best EC2.3–2.6 (winter); 2.8–3.3 (summer)[1]

A 2025 study from the Federal University of Paraná grew lettuce in a Kratky system at four nutrient strengths and found that the best EC for Kratky lettuce was well above the fertilizer label's 1.5 mS/cm: 2.3 to 2.6 mS/cm in winter and 2.8 to 3.3 mS/cm in summer.[1] The authors wrote that they found no earlier studies of the method in Brazil.[1] Their system differed from Kratky's in two ways that matter when reading the results: the plants were crowded and the solution was topped up during the crop.

How the study was set up

  • Place. A greenhouse without climate control, covered in clear polyethylene, with 50 percent shade net inside, at 807 m elevation in a humid temperate climate with hot summers.[1]
  • System. Six closed PVC channels, 3 m long and 0.1 m in diameter, spaced 20 cm apart and each filled with about 20 liters of solution. Each channel held 15 plants in 50 ml polystyrene pots perforated at the base.[1]
  • Treatments. Four channels each had one EC: 0.6, 1.5, 2.5 or 3.5 mS/cm. The fertilizer maker recommends 1.5 mS/cm for lettuce, and the other levels were set around it. Thirteen plants per channel were measured, 52 in all.[1]
  • Seasons. Seedlings raised for 20 days in phenolic foam were grown for 45 days in winter and 31 days in summer.[1]

Results

Fresh weight of the leafy part followed a curve with a peak in both seasons:[1]

Leaf fresh weight against EC[1]
SeasonPeak fresh weightAt ECShortfall at 1.5 mS/cm (label rate)Shortfall at 0.6 mS/cm
Winter (45 days)83.04 g2.58 mS/cm16 percent lower79 percent lower
Summer (31 days)118.32 g3.01 mS/cm20 percent lower77 percent lower
  • Leaf area and fresh weight, the parts a grower sells, peaked at EC 2.4 to 2.6 mS/cm in winter and 3.0 to 3.3 mS/cm in summer.[1]
  • Roots did best at 2.5 to 2.6 mS/cm in winter and 2.7 to 2.9 mS/cm in summer.[1]
  • Chlorophyll content did not differ between treatments in either season.[1]
  • The authors suggest higher summer humidity and faster vegetative growth as reasons the summer crop wanted a stronger solution.[1]

How it differs from Kratky's method

The study calls its system the Kratky method, and the roots grew the same way, but three practices differ from Kratky's own instructions:

  • Solution was added during the crop. The channels held only about 1.3 liters per plant at the start, roughly 75 percent less than the 5.6 liters the authors took from Kratky's 2005 paper, and they replenished the solution as the crop grew.[1] Kratky's method adds everything at the start and warns that raising the level can "drown" the oxygen roots.[2]
  • Plants were crowded. At 30 plants per square meter, density was about 50 percent above the maximum of 20 per square meter the authors cite from Kratky.[1]
  • pH was corrected. Any reading outside pH 6 to 7 was adjusted, with phosphoric acid only.[1] Kratky's Hawaii crops were usually completed without altering pH.[2]

Solution temperatures in the channels also reached 36 to 39 °C, though the authors saw no harm to the crop, which was harvested within normal commercial times.[1]

What it adds

Kratky started his lettuce tanks at about 1.5 mS.[2] This study suggests that in a warm climate, with one cultivar, a stronger solution gave more lettuce, and that the best strength changes with the season. Because the solution was topped up and the plants were crowded, the result applies most directly to systems run the same way. Kratky's broader water and nutrient figures are collected on Kratky method water use and nutrient use.

References

  1. da Silva, W.A.V., G. de Faria, O. Guedes Filho and R.B. Mazzini-Guedes (2025). "Hydroponic lettuce cultivated under different electrical conductivities in the Kratky method." Bragantia 84: e20250076. Open access. doi:10.1590/1678-4499.20250076.
  2. Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.