Kratky soil comparison trials (1988–1993)
Part of Kratky research notes. Background in the history of the Kratky method.
In his first papers on non-circulating hydroponics, Bernard Kratky measured his systems against the obvious benchmark: the same crop in soil. Three short reports from 1988 to 1993 found that non-circulating tomatoes yielded about as well as soil-grown tomatoes, and that capillary-tube lettuce yielded 24 percent more salable lettuce than soil.[1][2][3] This note summarizes their published abstracts.
The three trials
| Year | Crop | Non-circulating system | Result vs soil |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1988 | Tomato | Non-circulating hydroponic system | 3.5 kg per plant vs 3.1 kg in soil beds; statistically similar[1] |
| 1992 | Tomato 'Vendor', greenhouse | Four methods: three capillary sub-irrigated containers in 5 cm of solution, one rockwool block on a screen in a 20 cm tank | Salable yields not significantly different from soil beds (5.69 kg per plant)[2] |
| 1993 | Lettuce 'Green Ice' | Capillary tubes, bottom 25 mm in solution | 24 percent more salable yield than soil[3] |
Details
- 1992 containers. The sub-irrigated methods used 7 and 25 liter pots of a tree-fern and cinder medium holding one and two plants, and rockwool blocks resting on larger blocks, all in shallow, covered, polyethylene-lined tanks.[2]
- 1993 lettuce. Seedlings went into 218 mm plastic tubes holding 160 ml of medium; no fertilizing, watering or monitoring was needed from transplanting to harvest, and roots kept taking up water after the level fell below the tubes.[3] The design is covered under the capillary tube method.
Limits
These are short reports, and only their abstracts are freely available, so details such as replication, seasons and how the solution was managed during the tomato crops are not summarized here. A later study by other researchers compared Kratky-type lettuce with soil in Uganda; it is listed under Kratky method studies by other researchers.
References
- Kratky, B.A., J.E. Bowen and H. Imai (1988). "Observations on a noncirculating hydroponic system for tomato production." HortScience 23(5): 906–907. doi:10.21273/HORTSCI.23.5.906.
- Kratky, B.A. (1992). "Four non-circulating, hydroponic methods for growing greenhouse tomatoes." HortScience 27(6): 592 (abstract). doi:10.21273/HORTSCI.27.6.592d.
- Kratky, B.A. (1993). "A capillary, noncirculating hydroponic method for leaf and semi-head lettuce." HortTechnology 3(2): 206–207. doi:10.21273/HORTTECH.3.2.206.