Kratky air space study: lettuce in three systems (2005)

Part of Kratky research notes. Background in Kratky method research.

Study at a glance
AuthorB.A. Kratky[1]
JournalJournal of Vegetable Crop Production 11(2), 2005[1]
Crop'Red Sails' leaf lettuce[1]
Tanks8.9 cm high, 7.6 cm (109 L) of solution[1]
Crops grownSeven over one year[1]

Kratky's 2005 study asked the question at the heart of his method: does lettuce grow better when an air space opens between the tank cover and the solution? He compared a fixed cover, a cover that floated for the whole crop, and a cover that floated first and then came to rest on a 5 cm support. With the fixed cover, heads averaged 220 g; the floating cover gave heads 19 percent lighter, and the float-then-rest cover only 7 percent lighter.[1] He concluded that an air space with high relative humidity encouraged faster growth.[1]

How the study was set up

  • 'Red Sails' leaf lettuce grew in 5 cm net pots held by expanded polystyrene beadboard covers.[1]
  • Tanks were 8.9 cm high and held 7.6 cm (109 liters) of solution that was neither aerated nor circulated, with nothing added after the start.[1]
  • Lettuce was harvested when only 1.3 cm of solution remained, over seven crops in one year.[1]

Results

Head fresh weight by cover type[1]
CoverAir spaceHead weight
Fixed on the tank frameOpens as the level falls220 g average
Floating for the whole cropNone19 percent lower
Floating, then resting on a 5 cm supportOpens late in the crop7 percent lower

What came next

The float-then-rest idea became the float-support method. In 2008 Kratky and colleagues moved it to deeper 14 cm tanks with taller pipe supports, and reported that 10 cm supports gave yields as good as a fixed cover, while the 5 cm supports in 8.9 cm tanks had not always done so.[2] The same comparison for watercress is in watercress floating vs suspended cover.

References

  1. Kratky, B.A. (2005). "Growing lettuce in non-aerated, non-circulated hydroponic systems." Journal of Vegetable Crop Production 11(2): 35–42. doi:10.1300/J484v11n02_04 (abstract).
  2. Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.