Watercress floating vs suspended cover: Kratky's 2015 trials

Part of Kratky research notes. Background in Kratky method research.

Bulletin at a glance
AuthorB.A. Kratky, University of Hawaii CTAHR[1]
PublishedJune 2015, Vegetable Crops VC-7[1]
CropWatercress (Nasturtium officinale)[1]
SitesMealani (2,800 ft) and Volcano (4,000 ft) stations, Hawaii[1]
Tanks5½ in deep or deeper; EC 1.7–2.5 mS[1]
Crop time3 to 5 weeks from transplanting[1]

Kratky's 2015 bulletin on watercress tested the method's central idea, that roots need an air space, on a crop that grows naturally in water. It compared his suspended-cover tank, where an air space opens as the solution falls, with a floating cover that leaves no air space at all.[1] The answer was mixed: transplanted watercress yielded 17 to 22 percent more under the suspended cover, but direct-seeded watercress did about as well under either, and in one year-long trial the floating cover yielded 7 percent more.[1]

The two methods

Both methods use polyethylene-lined tanks at least 5½ inches deep, filled nearly to the top with nutrient solution, and 2-inch net pots of growing medium sown with 10 to 20 watercress seeds or planted with seedlings one to three weeks old.[1]

  • Suspended cover. The cover rests on the tank frame, with the lower ½ to 1 inch of each net pot in the solution. As the level drops below the pots, roots in the humid air between cover and solution become "oxygen roots". This is the same design as the covered tank method for lettuce.[1]
  • Floating cover. Extruded polystyrene sheets ½ to 1 inch thick float on the solution whatever its depth, so the lower 1 to 1½ inches of each pot stays in the solution and no air space forms. At least 2 inches of solution should remain at harvest.[1]

Results

Floating vs suspended covers for watercress[1]
TrialResult
Mealani, 8 harvests over one yearFloating cover higher in 3 harvests, similar in 5; 7 percent higher overall
Mealani, 2 further trialsSimilar yields
Volcano, 2 direct-seeded cropsSimilar yields
Volcano, transplanted 2-week-old seedlings, 12 weeksSuspended cover 17 percent higher
Volcano, transplanted 3-week-old seedlings, 12 weeksSuspended cover 22 percent higher

Roots grew more vigorously under the suspended cover, which Kratky attributed to the expanding moist air zone. He concluded that watercress may be grown with either cover, and advised growers to compare the two themselves.[1]

Other findings

  • Site. Over eight crops in rain shelters in one year, watercress yielded 32 percent more in 19 percent less time at the warmer Mealani station than at cooler Volcano.[1]
  • Season. At Volcano, December and January harvests yielded 34 percent less than March through July harvests; at Mealani, they were about 15 percent lower.[1]
  • Shade. A 40 percent shade fabric over the tanks cut yields by 15 percent over eight harvests.[1]
  • Changing the solution. For ratoon watercress harvested monthly, total yields after six months were 49 percent higher when the solution was completely changed every two months than when it was only topped off; a later 13-month trial reported 88 percent.[1]
  • Algae. A dark plastic strip over the gap between a floating cover and the tank sides reduced algae.[1]

Why watercress differs from lettuce

Kratky notes that watercress tolerates rain and other additions of water to the tank without the damage lettuce suffers in the suspended-pot method, so rain shelters are not mandatory for it.[1] For ratoon crops, the level can be kept up with periodic additions of solution.[1] For lettuce the evidence points the other way: a cover floating for the whole crop cut lettuce yields by up to 23 percent compared with a frame-supported cover.[2] More on that comparison is in Kratky method research.

References

  1. Kratky, B.A. (2015). Growing Direct-Seeded Watercress by Two Non-Circulating Hydroponic Methods. University of Hawaii CTAHR, Vegetable Crops VC-7. PDF.
  2. Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.