Low-cost Kratky system: the 2022 Uganda study

Part of Kratky research notes. Summarized in Kratky method studies by other researchers.

Study at a glance
AuthorsM.S. Gumisiriza, P.A. Ndakidemi, E.R. Mbega[1]
InstitutionNelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology, Arusha, Tanzania[1]
JournalMethodsX 9 (2022)[1]
SiteAn urban farm in Wakiso district, near Kampala, Uganda, 2021[1]
Unit60 lettuce plants in three 6 m PVC pipes on a wooden rack[1]
CostUS$170.70 per year[1]
PaybackAbout 8 months (4 cropping seasons)[1]

A 2022 study built a low-cost Kratky system for 60 lettuce plants from PVC pipe, a wooden rack and disposable cups, ran it outdoors on an urban farm near Kampala, Uganda, and found it profitable, with a payback period of about eight months.[1] The authors designed it for cities in developing countries, where they found soilless growing little used because of limited know-how and high start-up costs.[1]

How the unit was built

  • Rack. A three-level wooden rack 6 m long, with 60 cm between levels and 3 m tall, taking up 6 × 1 m of ground.[1]
  • Roof. A UV-resistant polyethylene roof 120 cm above the top level, for shade and to keep rain out.[1]
  • Pipes. One 6 m PVC pipe per level, with 20 holes 30 cm apart, capped at the ends. Small 2 cm holes at each end let air in.[1]
  • Pots. White disposable cups filled with sawdust and gravel under 1 cm, holding three-week-old seedlings.[1]
  • Pests. Blue and yellow sticky traps hung from the roof.[1]

A carpenter could build the rack and fit the roof in a day with one helper, and one worker could then raise the seedlings, transplant them and tend the crop to harvest.[1]

Growing the crop

The nutrient solution was a 19-19-19 water-soluble fertilizer mixed at 10 g per liter into 90 liters of water, then poured into the pipes at 30 liters each, about 1.5 liters per plant. A meter recorded an average pH of 5.9 and an average of 675 ppm dissolved solids.[1] Seeds were sown a month before transplanting, and the crop ran about two months from transplanting to the first harvest, with no fertilizer added.[1]

Costs and returns

Main costs of the unit, US dollars per year[1]
ItemCost
Wooden rack with UV plastic roof52.00
Fertilizer (6 kg)26.40
PVC pipes (3)21.00
pH control kit14.00
Dissolved-solids meter10.00
Water tank (100 L)9.00
Other items and sundries38.30
Total170.70

The same number of lettuce plants grown in soil-filled bags cost less, US$129.20, but took 8 × 2 m of space against 6 × 1 m and used 103 liters of water per crop against 90 liters.[1] The authors' economic analysis gave a net present value of US$16.37, an internal rate of return of 12.57 percent, a profitability index of 1.1, and a payback period of about eight months, or four cropping seasons.[1]

How it differs from Kratky's method

  • An air gap from day one. The authors left 2 to 3 cm between the bottom of each cup and the solution at planting, and drilled air holes in the pipes.[1] In Kratky's method the bottom of each pot starts in the solution, so the medium is wetted by capillary action until roots grow out.[2]
  • Less solution per plant. About 1.5 liters per plant, against the 4 to 8 liters per plant in Kratky's model system.[1][2]
  • Pipes, not a covered tank. The capped pipe plays the role of Kratky's covered tank, with the cups held in holes along its top.[1]

The same four principles are stated in the paper: humid air around the upper roots, roots never left without air, lower roots taking up water and nutrients, and a solution level that may stay the same or fall but is not raised.[1]

Limits the authors reported

Growth and maturity were inconsistent and slow during the study. The authors recommend more research into nutrient uptake, disease and temperature as possible causes.[1] A follow-up by the same group compared this lettuce with soil-grown lettuce; it is summarized under Kratky method studies by other researchers.

References

  1. Gumisiriza, M.S., P.A. Ndakidemi and E.R. Mbega (2022). "A simplified non-greenhouse hydroponic system for small-scale soilless urban vegetable farming." MethodsX 9: 101882. Open access. doi:10.1016/j.mex.2022.101882.
  2. Kratky, B.A. (2009). "Three non-circulating hydroponic methods for growing lettuce." Acta Horticulturae 843: 65–72. PDF.